Version 5.0

Here is version 5.0.  It's incorporated the most recent list of Jonathan Gold's 101 along with Los Angeles Magazine list of best restaurants.  It also includes Zagat, Gayot and Eater. Restaurants still need to appear on more two or more lists to qualify.  However, this list is greatly expanded because it includes restaurants listed on  Zagat down to 25/30 and Gayot all the way down to 14/20.

For this version, I normalized the the Yelp! rating also to a max of 3 points to match the other lists.

The first four lists (Gold, LA Magazine, Zagat, Gayot) contribute to the score depending on the ranking or rating.  Eater only acts to qualify restaurants if they also appear on at least one other list. A combined list of all Eater restaurants since October 2013 is compiled since the list changes quarterly.

Eater is worth 1 point regardless of position, since it's not really a ranking.  Eater only acts to qualify for the list because not appearing on this or any other list will also give 1 point.  The remaining lists are normalized to a maximum of three points.  The theoretical maximum score is 16.  Gold, Zagat, Gayot, Yelp! and LA Magazine contribute up to 3 points a piece and Eater just 1 point.

Stars are my personal rating.  I feel like my ratings are more objective than those coming from foodies, because I don't even like food.

Click here for a composite score with the meta-score plus my personal rating for the restaurants visited.

Click here for all the raw data with all the original rankings and scores for those restaurants making two or more lists.

Click on the name of the restaurants for links to reviews on Yelp!

RestaurantMetaListsMyScore
Providence15.424★★★★★
Melisse15.035★★★★
Spago14.505★★★★
n/naka13.914★★★★★
Hatfield's13.774★★★★
Ink13.635★★★½
Lucques13.593★★★½
Bestia13.435★★★★½
AOC13.245★★★
Angelini Osteria13.154★★★★
Rivera13.034★★★½
Alma13.024★★★½
Osteria Mozza12.983★★★
Marche Moderne12.953★★★★
Drago Centro12.914★★★½
Animal12.884★★★★
Vincenti12.814★★½
Saam12.663★★★★½
Orsa & Winston12.513
Shunji12.473★★★★
Trois Mec12.324★★★½
Son of a Gun12.244★★★★
Cut12.233★★★★
Rustic Canyon12.154★★★★
Picca12.065★★★½
Matsuhisa12.054★★★★
Night + Market12.054★½
Tasting Kitchen12.033★★★½
Tar & Roses11.943★★★½
The Bazaar11.923★★★★
Baco Mercat11.734★★★½
Urasawa11.703★★★★★
M.B. Post11.694★★★½
Red Medicine11.603★★★★
Hart & the Hunter11.474★★★★
Tsujita11.444★★★★
Corazon y Miel11.443★★★½
Bucato11.434★★★★
Allumette11.393★★★★
Sotto11.393★★★½
Gjelina11.375★★★½
Valentino11.363★★★★
Jar11.303★★★½
Kiriko11.283★★★★
Asanebo11.282★★★★½
Joe's11.213★★★★
Newport Seafood11.153★★★
Connie & Ted's11.153★★★★
Patina11.124★★★★
Craft11.093
Saddle Peak Lodge11.063
Josie11.063★★★
The Hungry Cat10.893★★★½
Park's BBQ10.874★★★½
Watergrill10.834★★★
Marouch10.812★★½
Hinoki & the Bird10.783★★★½
Maude10.712★★★★½
Republique10.652
Hamasaku10.652★½
Sea Harbour10.633★★★½
Bashan10.622★★★★
Jitlada10.573
Girasol10.532★★★½
Chi Spacca10.513★★★★½
Q10.502
Cooks County10.472
Sqirl10.462
Farmshop10.413
Langer's10.383★★★★
Brandywine10.372
Sushi Sushi10.372
Mori Sushi10.322
Din Tai Fung10.163★★★
Shiro10.072
Playground10.062
Mastro's10.032★★★½
Sushi Sasabune10.032
Taco Maria9.992
Maison Akira9.982
Chengdu Taste9.982
La Casita Mexicana9.953★★½
Church & State9.922★★★½
Bludso's9.872
Fig9.852
Chichen Itza9.832★★★½
Katsu-Ya9.772★★★
Nobu Malibu9.773
Shima9.772
Capo9.732
JiRaffe9.732★★★
K-Zo9.732
Nobu Los Angeles9.732★★★
Parkway Grill9.732★★★
Takao9.732
The Larchmont9.732
Petrossian9.702★★★★
Crossroads9.682
Chinois on Main9.682
The Belvedere9.682
Racion
9.67
2
Il Grano9.60
2
★★★
L&E Oyster Bar9.55
3
★★★½
Superba Snack Bar9.48
3
Bouchon9.45
2
★★★½
Black Market9.44
2
Golden Deli9.44
2
★★★
Ado9.40
2
Oliverio9.40
2
Palmeri Ristorante9.40
2
Ruth's Chris9.40
2
★★★
Sam's by the Beach9.40
2
The Raymond9.40
2
Toscana9.40
2
Bay Cities9.37
2
★★★
Tavern9.28
2
Petty Cash Taqueria9.22
3
Border Grill9.17
2
★★★
Celestino9.10
2
Crustacean9.10
2
La Pergola9.10
2
WP249.10
2
Pizzeria Mozza9.07
2
★★
Guelaguetza8.99
2
★★
Sugarfish8.73
2
★★★½
Milo & Olive8.51
2
Sushi Park8.40
2

No comments:

Post a Comment